Cults and Crazy Thinking

by John Edmiston

diagram

Cults "think differently". Its a complex issue and some tool is needed so we can quickly evaluate whether a group is a genuine religious movement or a dangerous cult group. Over the last ten years of ministry to cults I have developed some tools that help me to help others improve their judgement. Such tools have to be simple, transferable and memorisable so they can sit in the person's memory and pop up when needed - a little bit like a TSR I suppose. The above diagram is one such tool. Its meant to be memorised. Its meant to be simple. And its meant to work as an elementary tool for evaluating religious groups and their leaders. Well here goes!

The first of our "three dimensions" on the diagram is the Love-Hate dimension. It could also be labeled Unconditional Love vs Paranoid Thinking. The key test is the question "How do they treat their enemies?'. A paranoid group goes from suspicion to suspicion, living in fear and employing "guilt by association" to mark people as those to beware of. A paranoid cult group is preoccupied with its fortress mentality, its thought life is disproportionately centred around warding off evil rather than pursuing good. While guarding against sin and compromise is an essential part of the Christian life being paranoid is not! Jesus was sinless - but He still loved His enemies and prayed for those who persecuted Him.

The second dimension is that of wisdom versus foolishness. Another name for it might be "love of the truth wherever it can be found" vs "creation of an authoritarian and idiosync ratic reality". Cults believe they have a monopoly on Truth and create their own, often quite idiosynratic "reality". Cults tend to create untestable, unverifiable "worlds of their own", and abound in bizarre conspiracy theories, quaint world-views, mystical and other-worldly perspectives. While the man or woman of faith will sometimes see life very differently they do not disregard the insights of others. The fool says "my system is all I need". In cults and bizarre religious sects there is no searching for objective Truth , rather there is a loud and clamant glorying in one's own "wisdom". Such people are among those that bombard the Internet with posts all in "caps" and full of strange sounding jargon that sets you on edge when you read it. Their claims are often untestable as they may be set in the future or in dreams or visions that the reader has no way of verifying. When their claims can be checked out, they generally prove to be inaccurate. Cults limit the outside information available to recruits and enmesh them in this alternate reality. It is often the quest for objective truth that causes some recruits to question and finally to leave the cult.

The third dimension is that of mercy versus cruelty. These terms are quite accurate in my view. All you need to do to be cruel is to think exclusively of yourself. People in cults don't "hate" their families in general - they just do not see them, care for them, or meet their needs. Cults develop a very inward form of thinking where the recruit spends most of their time either working for the cult or pondering their own deficiencies. This phenomenal self-absorption can cause parents to neglect their children and several have died as a result of parents refusing basic medical treatment on religious grounds. Jesus never asked anyone to throw away their medicines! Cults neglect the needs of the outer world and their social action programmes are practically non-existent. Where they do exist they tend to focus on cult members or be thinly disguised recruiting mechanisms. The "mainline churches" are extensively involved on caring for those outside of their membership and many of the best hospitals, schools and rehabilitation programmes are run by them. Though cults are large (about a quarter of the size of the mainline churches) their contribution in these areas is small indeed.

Lets consider applying the model to three "real life" people - Hitler, Jim Jones and David Koresh. All had well-defined "enemies" which they guarded against and were pre-occupied with. They were characterised by paranoid thinking on dimension one. On the dimension of wisdom versus foolishness though all were quite clever and manipulative people they were not "wise". They all had their own reality that they followed in total disregard of objective Truth and biblical wisdom. On the dimension of mercy versus cruelty - mercy is about the last thing we assocaite with thier names! All three score strongly on the dimension of cruel disregard of others. All three men eventually caused the death of themselves and their followers. Whether it be Hitler, Jim Jones or David Koresh when we examine their attitude using this model they are all at the dangerous lower left hand corner of the diagram. If you are aware of a group near you whose leadership fits this model feel free to e-mail Eternity Magazine and we will do our best to help.

To test the model on "positive" religious figures I chose Jesus, St Francis of Assisi, and Billy Graham. All three are loving people and though they all experienced intense public criticism they all weathered it without rancour. They are noted for forgiving their enemies. On the wisdom/foolishness dimension while each had strong life-dominating calls there was no disregard for truth. Jesus as a child sat with the Rabbis in the temple, St Francis submitted to the tecahings of the Catholic Church and Billy Graham stands squarely in the middle of mainstream evangelicalism. All three had a gentle wisdom from God not a noisy clamour from the self. And mercy is something we assocaite immediately with Jesus and St Francis and also to some extent with Billy Graham. They bless people. Jesus died for others. They helped the poor. They were utterly self-giving. Our model places them in the upper right hand corner - diamterically opposite that of the cult leaders!

So by using this model we see that a cult like the Branch Davidians may be Christian in name but in nature it can be shown to the polar opposite of "true Christianity" as exemplified by Jesus, St Francis and Billy Graham..

I hope you find this model helpful and useful. It is meant to stick in your minds and be a simple and usable tool for evaluating the dynamics of a religious group. If you have any questions about it or would like a more full explanation of some points feel free to e-mail me at johnedmiston@jed.org,au - Lots of blessings!

John Edmiston
John Edmiston

Eternity Magazine
Article reproduced with permission of Eternity Magazine




Bible
Why Study Prophecy?
God intends that we understand the contents of the prophetic Word and that it will have a bearing upon the practical decisions we Christians make.


Baha'i World Faith

A growing modern ecumenical movement.

Wake Up!
There is a storm coming!


Bible Prophecy Resources
Learn more about Bible prophecy

Christian Dating



Click Here for Bestselling Books


CrossDaily.com